The Truth About Selling Your Mortgage Broking Business: Are You Cashing Out or Tapping Out?

Selling Your Business: The Dream vs. The Reality

For many mortgage brokers, selling their business is the ultimate endgame—the big payday, the final victory lap. Cash out, walk away, and sail into the sunset. It sounds like the dream, doesn’t it?

But the reality is far less glamorous.

Most business sales don’t deliver the financial windfall that owners expect. Instead, many end up selling for a fraction of their perceived value, often shackled to earnout agreements that keep them working for years—just without control. Worse still, some realise too late that they didn’t really want to sell in the first place; they just wanted relief from the pressures of running their business.

Before you decide to sell, it’s critical to understand the real reasons behind your desire to exit and ensure you’re making a strategic decision—not an emotional one. Because here’s the truth: most mortgage broking business owners don’t actually want to sell. They just want freedom.

So, let’s break it down. When does selling make sense? When is it a mistake? And—perhaps most importantly—is there a better way?

When Does Selling Your Mortgage Broking Business Make Sense?

There are a few key scenarios where selling might actually be the right move. If you’re in one of these situations, a sale could be the best way to maximize your return and transition to your next chapter on your terms.

1. You’re Burnt Out and Don’t Want to Fix It

Burnout is real. Running a mortgage broking business takes stamina, especially when managing client expectations, staff, compliance, and industry shifts. If you’ve reached a point where you simply don’t have the energy or motivation to reinvest in the business—mentally, financially, or emotionally—then selling might be your best option.

However, a word of caution: distressed businesses don’t attract top dollar. If your business is struggling due to declining revenue, operational inefficiencies, or an over-reliance on you as the owner, potential buyers will see the risk and discount their offers accordingly.

If you’re in this position, it’s worth considering whether burnout is temporary or if you genuinely have no desire to keep going. If there’s a chance that restructuring your role or bringing in operational support could reignite your passion, that’s an alternative worth exploring before heading straight for the sale.

2. You Have a Bigger Opportunity Elsewhere

Some mortgage brokers are serial entrepreneurs at heart. If you have another business venture or investment that could 10x your returns, then selling your broking business to free up time, energy, and capital could be a smart move.

But be realistic. Is the new opportunity genuinely more lucrative, or is it just an escape hatch from the challenges of your current business? Too often, owners jump ship only to realise the grass wasn’t greener—it was just a different shade of the same problem.

3. The Purchase Price Exceeds 3-5 Years of Net Profit

A simple financial rule of thumb: if someone offers you more than 3-5 years’ worth of net profit, it’s worth serious consideration.

Here’s why: If your business generates $500K in net profit annually, and you receive an offer for $2.5M+, you’re essentially getting paid upfront for what you’d take home over the next 5 years anyway—without the workload or risk.

However, if your business is thriving and capable of running without you (more on this below), it may be worth holding on, implementing a succession strategy, and collecting passive income instead.

4. The Business Can Run Without You

This is the golden ticket for any business sale. If your mortgage broking business operates smoothly without your daily involvement—meaning it has strong leadership, repeatable processes, and a self-sustaining client pipeline—then buyers will pay a premium.

If, on the other hand, your business is entirely dependent on you, you won’t be selling a business—you’ll be selling a job. And buyers don’t pay a premium for a job. Instead, they’ll insist on an earnout agreement, where you continue working under new ownership for several years to “transition” the business.

For many business owners, this is the worst of both worlds: you’ve given up control but still have all the responsibilities.

Why Most Brokers Don’t Actually Want to Sell

At Recludo, we work with mortgage broking business owners every day, and here’s what we’ve discovered:

Most brokers don’t actually want to sell. They want:

• More freedom – to step out of the daily grind and focus on the parts of the business they enjoy.

• More profit – to keep reaping the financial rewards without working 80-hour weeks.

• More control – to run the business on their terms, not someone else’s.

If that resonates with you, then selling might not be the best move. Instead, you should consider how to Exit Without Selling—a strategy that allows you to keep your business, step back from day-to-day operations, and still collect a paycheck.

Exit Without Selling: The Smarter Alternative

So, what does “exiting without selling” look like?

Step 1: Remove Yourself as the Bottleneck

If your business can’t function without you, it’s not really a business—it’s just you with a team around you.

Start by delegating key functions. Build leadership within your team. Invest in systems and processes that allow the business to operate independently of you. This increases the value of your business whether you sell or not.

Step 2: Implement a Succession Strategy

A well-structured succession plan ensures that ownership and operational control can transition smoothly—without the need for an outright sale. This might involve:

• Grooming an internal successor (e.g., a key team member or general manager)

• Creating an equity-based incentive plan to retain top talent

• Structuring a management buyout where you retain an interest but step back from daily operations

• Recapitalizing the business in a partnership with Private Equity

Step 3: Create Passive Income Streams

If you don’t want to sell but also don’t want to work full-time, the goal is to generate passive income from your business. This could involve:

• Setting up a profit-share model where you retain ownership but collect distributions

• Licensing systems or technology you’ve built to other brokers

• Transitioning from direct client work to coaching, consulting, or mentoring

This way, you get the best of both worlds: ownership without the daily headaches.

The Bottom Line: Sell for the Right Reasons

Selling your mortgage broking business is a major decision—one that shouldn’t be driven by exhaustion or frustration alone.

If you genuinely want out and have a great offer on the table, go for it.

But if what you really want is freedom, financial security, and control over your future—there’s a better way.

At Recludo, we specialise in helping mortgage broking business owners build valuable, independent, self-sustaining businesses. Whether you’re looking to sell or exit without selling, we can help you navigate the path to a more prosperous, balanced, and fulfilling next chapter.

If that sounds like the conversation you need to have, let’s talk.

[Schedule a Call]